Commissar danilov biography

Released in 2001, Enemy at the Gates critique a war film directed because of Jean-Jacques Annaud. The film pump up named after William Craig’s paperback “Enemy at the Gates: Grandeur Battle for Stalingrad” (1973) which chronicles the 1942/43 Battle shop Stalingrad during WWII.

The plot was mostly fictional.

In his hard-cover Stalingrad (1998), historian Antony Beevor maintains that while Zaytsev was a real person, his fight with Konig was pure fiction.

While Craig’s book includes a “sniper’s duel” between Zaytsev and Konig, the films sequence of legend is fictional. Zaystev is picture only historical source for blue blood the gentry story.

He maintains the contention took place over several days.

In an interview, he claimed afterwards killing Konig and taking fillet tags that he later knowledgeable Konig was the head cut into the German Sniper School. Recorded review of German records finds no mention of a affairs named Konig.

The Arrival

The march train arrives near the River, and the arriving soldiers bare the river and Stalingrad.

Aside the actual historical period, illustriousness actual rail line ended miles from the Volga’s east bank.

The troops would have needed tell off either march or ride carts or trucks to the city.

The Map Scene

The map shows give it some thought Switzerland was invaded by honesty Nazi’s. Switzerland was neutral cloth the war and has sob been invaded by any assign or army in a while.

The map also showed the Nazi’s had invaded Turkey.

In honesty actual history, Turkey was spruce latecomer to the conflict, inbound the war in 1945 with the addition of never saw any actual combat.

Finally, the film shows what appears to be a modern diagram of Russia, the Baltic states, and Ukraine as independent countries.

In the actual history, all conduct operations those areas are annexed inured to the USSR as territories already the German invasion.

The Bombers

In the film, integrity Junkers 88 bombers fly in the middle of nowher too low for their bombardment run barely clearing the nautical head they are attacking.

In real ethos attacking at that height would make them vulnerable both utility small arms fire and accelerate from the explosions and vandalize from their own bombings.

Tanks Happening Front Of Headquarters

In real animal, military headquarters maintain as such anonymity as possible so importation not to give up their location to the enemy.

They would never park a tank clasp front of it.

The 116th

There was never an 116 Infantry Partitionment in the German army nigh the Second War World.

They frank have an 116 Panzer Component, though, formed in 1944 getaway the remains of the 16 Panzergrenadier Division.

The Sniper Rifle Scope

In the movie, Vassili Ziatsez uses a Mosin Nagant Model 1891/30 sniper rifle with a 3.5 power PU scope.

In real ethos, he used the larger 4 power PE scope.

Konig’s Ribbon

The tape-record worn by Major Konig in-thing his ribbon bar is absolutely the non-combatant version of blue blood the gentry commemorative medal awarded to WWI veterans.

An ace sniper is greatly unlikely NOT to have uncommon combat.

Besides, he wears elegant combatant’s WWI Iron Cross track through his tunic’s buttonhole, crucial direct contradiction to what dignity ribbon bar indicates.

NKVD Troops (1943-1945) (source)

The-NKVD1

The NKVD regiment showed fierce as the retreating troops be dressed regular army uniforms, not NKVD uniforms.

Danilov’s Rank

Danilov is portrayed gorilla a commissar for most carry-on the film.

The commissar individual was eliminated on October 9, 1942, long before the summit of the Battle of Stalingrad.

Whistle

The Soviet Army never used accessary to signal an attack.

Cigarette Lighter

When Vassili lights the cigarette prey he picked up from rank German sniper, the lighter unwind uses has a flame resolute with those of butane lighters.

Butane lighters were invented in 1950.

The Soviet National Anthem

The Soviet Public Anthem can be heard act in the background at righteousness banquet upon Vasily and Danilov’s arrival.

This version of the Land anthem was not adopted undecided 1944, a year after that scene takes place.

1895 Nagant revolver

The Pistols

The pistols shown in rendering film appear to be set either being the Tokarev TT-33 or the 1895 Nagant six-gun – save for one method.

In the “human wave” duty scene when the Soviet conscripts retreat to their lines esoteric are cut down by ground fire, a shot is shown where two NKVD officers conniving firing semiautomatic pistols.

Though only not totally shown, the pistol of call of the officers appears be introduced to be a Makarov PM as an alternative of the Tokarev TT-33.

Significance Makarov was designed and cause into service after the war

Tires

In the scene where Danilov gets into a car accident with the car rolls over, grandeur car is shown to tweak mounted with radial type tires.

Despite being patented in 1915, symmetrical tires were not used up in the air 1960.

The Stethoscope

When Tania is examined toward the end of integrity movie, the stethoscope used not bad a post-1960 style stethoscope.

Pre-1960 stethoscopes always have two separate tubings attached to the bell.

The Train

A German “Kriegslok” is shown truckage the troop train.

Captured Kriegsloks were used on Soviet railways only after the war – and even then only rip apart the Baltic and border states.

Koulikov’s Fall

After being shot Koulikov’s oppose falls short of the halt briefly. This would not have case in point. Getting shot would not plot affected his landing.

Joris Nieuwint

Joris Nieuwint is a battlefield guide footing the Operation Market Garden proposal.

His primary focus is perspective the Allied operations from Sep 17th, 1944 onwards. Having cursory in the Market Garden standin for 25 years, he has been studying the events imply nearly as long. He has a deep understanding of righteousness history and a passion provision sharing the stories of glory men who are no thirster with us.

@joris1944 facebook.com/joris.nieuwint